BLACK FRIDAY! 20% OFF EVERYTHING + Free Shipping! Discount automatically applied at checkout. Free shipping on all USA orders xx

What’s up with Toasted?

At Toasted, we’re a small, passionate team of young women hand crafting small batch jewelry with care, magic, and intention like our lives depend on it in Santa Cruz, CA. Since 2016, we’ve been perfecting our craft to bring you high quality pieces made to stay tarnish-free, durable, and survive real life. Our pieces speak for themselves: no paid collabs, no fake hype, no staged bathroom-mirror try-ons. Just real jewelry made & worn by real girls. Because everything is made in-house, we skip the middleman and keep our prices honest, so you get elevated jewelry without the markup. Enjoy free shipping on all U.S. orders and easy returns, because we’re not here to stress you out. At Toasted, we’ll always have your back.

NOW OPEN

We couldn't be more thrilled to announce that we have opened our second storefront in the heart of Pleasure Point, Santa Cruz CA. It will be a Toasted experience you've never had before. Exclusive jewelry designs, custom merch and permanent jewelry everyday, walk-ins only.

Pleasure Point shop:

925 41st Avenue Santa Cruz CA 95062

Westside shop (our first baby):

1010 Fair Ave G Santa Cruz CA 95060

Proud doner to the Breast Cancer Research Foundation, who's mission is to prevent and cure breast cancer by advancing the world’s most promising research.

New Arrivals

  • $80.00
    $80.00
    Sold out
  • $40.00
    $40.00
    Sold out
  • Toasted x Santa Cruz Embroidered Beanie - Toasted Jewelry
    $40.00
    $40.00
    Sold out
  • Pearl Moon Hoops - Two Sizes! - Toasted Jewelry
    from $95.00
    from $95.00
    Sold out
View all

Customer Testimonials

Toasted not only has the best jewelry but outstanding customer service. I always get compliments on my jewelry, especially my rings! I can't wait to see what new designs they come up with."

Alexis W.

I've always had a difficult time finding jewelry that was cute and also didn't look cheap. Toasted jewelry is the only jewelry I wear now because they look great whether it's a casual outfit or a going out outfit. Amazing designs, beautifully crafted, and a truly great company!

Zoe T.

Every piece I own is handcrafted beautifully! They are the perfect pieces to dress up or pair for every day wear. My family and friends and family totally have definitely caught on to my love for Toasted as I was gifted new pieces for Christmas this year!

Carli R.

Toasted Jewelry is my favorite out of my whole collection! Always arrives quick.

Dahlia N.

I love and wear my mini huggies every day. They never tarnish and they go with everything.

Alexa K.

My Freshwater Keshi Pearl Ring will be cherished forever and is the perfect ring!

Anela G.

I love Toasted! I wear my gold rings and earrings 24/7 even when surfing and no tarnishing at all!

Meghan M.

So cute and perfect for everyday wear. I haven't taken my rings off since I got them!

Lindsey D.

Toasted is my go to! Whenever my partner asks what I want for a special occasion... it's this!

Shannon

Love Toasted soooo much! Whenever I wear it I feel beautiful!

Kelsey B.

Everything I have from Toasted is of the highest quality! I’m notoriously pretty hard on my jewelry and while the pieces are dainty and cute, they are all very hardy and built to last-I’m so glad to know these pieces will be with me forever!

Tara (Owner, Golden Bee Apothecary)

So happy with all of my Toasted purchases over the years! The quality is amazing.

Georgia K.

In love with my Toasted pieces! Love the fact that even after 4 years they haven't tarnished.

Claire A.

Stacking Rings and bangles are gorgeous! Super high quality. Never took them off! :)

Katie K.

Love my Toasted jewelry so much! Wear it all day everyday! Love the shimmer in the sun!

Gloria O.

I've been wearing Toasted for years now and it's my favorite go to small business for earrings!

Sarah S.

You're Toasted.

Tag us on Instagram in your photos to be featured. Follow us for secret sales and announcements.

@toastedjewelry
Liquid error (layout/theme line 204): Could not find asset snippets/shopstar-initializer.liquid